|
Forensic Psychiatric Diagnosis and Criminal Responsibility: Reassessing Article 149 of the Islamic Penal Code through Contemporary Forensic Psychiatric Evaluations
|
Mohammad Khani *  |
| Assistant Professor, Department of Criminal Law and Criminology, Neyshabur Branch, Islamic Azad University, Neyshabur, Iran , mohammad.khani@iau.ac.ir |
|
|
Abstract: (59 Views) |
Aims: Article 149 of the Iranian Islamic Penal Code links criminal non-responsibility due to mental disorder to loss of volitional capacity or discernment at the time of the offence, whereas psychiatric classifications serve clinical diagnosis. This study examined the evidentiary limits of forensic psychiatric diagnosis under Article 149 and identified components of a judicially reviewable expert report.
Methods: A qualitative documentary analysis with an interdisciplinary legal-psychiatric approach was conducted. The final corpus included 35 sources: 28 peer-reviewed articles and 7 legal or professional sources. Data were coded across four domains: diagnosis, reconstruction of offence-time mental state, functional impairment, and application to the legal standard.
Findings: Diagnosis alone neither establishes criminal non-responsibility nor demonstrates impairment of legally relevant capacities. Key weaknesses include overreliance on diagnostic labels, temporal distance from the offence, inconsistent expert opinions, and lack of a standardized format linking symptoms to conduct. Evidence supports retrospective reconstruction, collateral information, functional analysis, and explicit reporting of limitations and confidence.
Conclusion: Article 149 is sufficiently functional to accommodate advances in psychiatry. The principal need is to standardize translation of diagnosis into legally relevant expert opinion. A national protocol should structure evaluation around diagnosis, reconstruction of the offence-time mental state, functional assessment, and judicial application.
|
|
| Keywords: Forensic Psychiatry, Insanity Defense, Mental Disorders |
|
|
|
Type of Article: Research Article |
Subject:
Medical Law Received: 2026/09/4 | Revised: 2026/11/21 | Accepted: 2026/11/21
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Send email to the article author |
|
|